Psalm 8 and Romans 5:1–5
There is a wonderfully campy song by Sir Arthur Sullivan that is particularly appropriate for this day.
It's about an organist who, according to the lyrics, is “weary and ill at ease” With “fingers wandering idly” the poor soul “knew not what they were playing” but, says the musician then, quite out of the blue “I struck one chord of music, Like the sound of a great Amen.”
This one chord is so wonderful, so marvelous, that the rest of the piece is given over to the search to find it again which is why this high camp number is called “The Lost Chord” and it is classic Sullivan even though its words were not written by his operetta partner Sir William Gilbert with everything we have come to expect from his compositions.
I’ve heard some famous organists include it their programs just for fun but I think the song may have a deeper meaning. I think this finding “a lost chord” and then searching every key on the keyboard to try and recreate it is about the wonder of an awe that comes into our lives at unexpected moments to leave us surprised, delighted, and longing for more.
Awe is a fleeting thing that comes into our lives when we least expect it.
In Saint Luke’s ongoing search to find a new pastor which is now into its fifth year burning through two interims with mine well into its third year (And you folks think you had problems!) one of my suggestions has been that the call committee should ask every candidate two things.
The first is that any person who is candidating for the position of pastor be asked to tell the committee their favorite joke.
If he or she blushes, or hems and haws, the committee might guess that the joke was unseemly at which point I would strongly suggest hiring him or her on the spot because the church can use a little relief from priggish silliness and just get back to pure, unadulterated silliness. As an institution the church as a whole takes itself far too seriously.
The second question is courtesy of Dr. Scott Black Johnston, the Senior Minister of the Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church in New York. He has asked it of candidates who wanted to become ordained or join his staff. In order to discover whether a person regularly experienced any sense of wonder he would ask: “When was the last time you experienced awe?” Awe, is like the sensation that came over the organist who stumbled upon a chord that was never thought to be heard this side of heaven.
It is a good question for all of us to ponder. “When was the last time we experienced awe?”
Awe and wonder are hard to define but we know when we are experiencing them.
Someone who appreciates art may experience awe and wonder in a Degas’ dancer, a water lilly by Monet, Van Gogh’s “Starry Night,” a Georgia O’Keefe landscape, or even a creation by one of the second graders at Saint Luke Academy.
A music lover may experience awe and wonder when a performance all comes together with a grand chord on the end, smiles on the face of the performers, and the silence of an audience that has to catch its breath before bursting into applause.
Someone who loves the outdoors may experience awe and wonder when seeing The Grand Canyon, or the Rockies, or the ocean, or a mighty river, or a wide field of wheat glistening in the sun.
For those who love language it may be that well-turned phrase that makes us roar with laughter, or put down the book, stare off into space for a moment in awe of what we have just read.
You know what I am talking about. As Dr. Johnston explains it. “Awe is an open mouth, a sudden gasp of air, wide eyes, a twisted smile. Awe is something that makes our hearts leap. Experiencing awe and wonder seem to be a central part of what it means to be human.”1
It is also a central part of our experiences of the Divine which seems to come to us in many ways.
The psalmist described awe this way: “O Lord, our Lord, how majestic is thy name in all the earth! Thou whose glory above the heavens is chanted..."2
In his book Where the Rivers Flow, Scott Walker describes the awe he felt late at night walking home after an evening of cruising around his small Georgia town looking for, in his words, “beautiful damsels awaiting us, longing to be spirited away from the dragons of boredom.”
At the close of the evening when he and his friends returned home alone probably because of their lame pick up line – “Are you a damsel I can spirit away from boredom?” – Walker would walk alone down his driveway into his back yard were there were “huge pecan trees, and behind our rear hedge grew acres and acres of peach trees.
Inevitably, I would look up into the night sky, for it has always held my deepest fascination. It has been my cathedral, my high-vaulted place of worship, my dark blanket that brought me the warmth of God. Conversely, it has also been the eternal stage on which I have been brought into interplay with the stark fear and awe of the Holy. 3
Like the song the rest of the book is given over to Walker’s search for the same awe and wonder he felt in his backyard as a teenage boy.
It’s a search that all of us are on. We are all looking for that “lost chord” but here is the secret, its not something we can create.
Believe me, the wise preacher does not get up on Sunday morning and say, “I’m going to preach the most awe-inspiring sermon in the history of Christendom.” Allow yourself to think that and if the congregation is still awake when you finish, you’ll be lucky to be met at the door with a wet fish handshake and, as they used to say in Mayberry, a “fine Sabaoth Reverend” greeting.
Start by thinking you're going to create the most beautiful piece of music, or most beautiful painting, and you’ll come away disappointed because “awe” is an act of the spirit.
You’ll never know when it will sneak up on you, but you’ll know it when it does. Awe is something that must surprise.
It is an act of the spirit. Not the fall on the floor and speak in unknown languages spirit but a spirit that you feel, experience, that seems to come out of the blue.
That’s the kind of Spirit Saint Paul was talking about.
Dr. Bruce Larson wrote in his book Wind and Fire. “Anybody can discern whether or not the Spirit is present in a gathering. You feel loved, cared for, and accepted.”
You may be impressed by the grandeur of the architecture. You may fall in loved by the art collection on the walls. But if you walk away, unloved, uncared for, unaccepted, in spite of everything else you’ll feel something is missing. Because it is “the Spirit ...who communicates His presences and produces life and hope.”4
Saint Paul invited his congregation then and our congregations now to “cling to that hope, even if things don't look exactly the way that they thought they would look, that didn't go exactly the way they thought they would go - that God's hope is the common thread that is woven through the experience of not just us individually as followers of Jesus, but as the entire collection of those in the way of Jesus."5
Hope comes to us in the awe we experience in creation, the warmth of the Spirit, and the love of Jesus.
That surprisingly enough is what Trinity Sunday is all about.
And I am going to show you what Trinity is all about with the help of our esteemed director of Music. Andy on his final day is going to also become a preacher this morning.
First, Andy is just going to play a “G” for us on the organ. Think of that note as the creator. A perfectly wonderful note, but just a single note.
Now Andy is going to play a “G” and then add it to an “E”. Still good but not quite fulfilling as a piece of music.
Finally, Andy is going to add a “C” to the “E” and the “G”. What do we have? A chord. Each note is not complete without the others but what we have is a Trinity of notes from which much music can be made.
So, there you have it. It may not be the “lost chord” nor may it have left you with a sense of awe but it is an example of what we mean when we say Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
And a pretty good example at that. Don’t you think?
________________
1. Scott Black Johnson, “Wired for Wonder.” Sermon preached at the Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church of New York City. September 10, 2023.
2. Psalm 8. (RSV) [RSV=The Revised Standard Version]
3. Scott Walker, Where the Rivers Flow: Exploring the Sources of Faith Development (Macon, , Ga: Smyth & Helwys, 2002), 37-38.
4. Bruce Larson, Wind and Fire (Waco, Texas: Word Books, 1985), 38.
5. Danny Lybarger, “Hope That Doesn’t Quit” - Episode #4186: Day 1,” Episode #4184. Day 1, June 10, 2025, https://day1.org/weekly-broadcast/6835acc06615fbab5100b23f/hope-that-doesnt-quit-4186-rev-danny-lybarger-romans-5-1-5-june-15-2025.
Sermon Preached at Our Savior Lutheran Church Aurora
To experience the conclusion:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X19VSzJ5tBo